A federal prosecutor on Thursday urged jurors in Boston to convict four Teamsters union members charged with trying in 2014 to extort jobs from a production company filming “Top Chef” through tactics that included threatening host Padma Lakshmi.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Kristina Barclay told the federal jury in her closing argument that the Teamsters threatened the Bravo network cooking competition show’s cast and crew, with one telling Lakshmi he would “bash her pretty little face in.”
Barclay said the Teamsters during a shoot in the suburb of Milton yelled racist and homophobic slurs, slashed tires and threatened to shut down filming to secure wages for unnecessary services from the non-union production.
But lawyers for Daniel Redmond, John Fidler, Robert Cafarelli and Michael Ross said they were engaged in legitimate picketing as their union negotiated to have the company replace non-union drivers with its Teamsters Local 25 members.
Kevin Barron, a lawyer for Ross, urged jurors to look past “emotional evidence” and consider whether his client intended to extort anyone or was just part of a protest that turned ugly.
“Is there extortion going on or is this a protest?” he said. “You have to ask yourself that.”
Prosecutors contend that on June 5, 2014, Redmond approached the show’s crew while it was filming at a hotel, demanded union members be hired as drivers and told a producer to call his union supervisor.
Barclay said after another Boston hotel grew concerned about picketing and withdrew from participating in the show, production company Magical Elves was forced last-minute to film at the Steel & Rye restaurant in Milton.
That June 10, Redmond, Fidler, Cafarelli and Ross showed up at the restaurant, where they threatened crew members and blocked vehicles, Barclay said.
She cited witnesses who testified that some Teamsters also swarmed a van bringing Lakshmi to the set, including Fidler, who she said told the host: “We’re going to bash your pretty little face in.”
Lawyers for the defendants questioned how well the memories of the government’s witnesses had held up since the 2014 event and whether the supposed threat to Lakshmi happened as witnesses claimed.
“This is all exaggeration,” said Oscar Cruz, a lawyer for Redmond. “This is all Hollywood film industry people who don’t like being called names and don’t like being harassed.”
“I was a judge on that season,” the Starving for Attention podcast host recently told PEOPLE at Santa Margherita’s She Shed in Brooklyn, New York. “I remember it in the moment as being a thing that was happening, but none of it happened while I was around … so I can’t talk about it firsthand.”
Still, Blais unwaveringly supports his costar of many seasons on the Bravo culinary competition, who testified in court last week that she felt physically “threatened” by one of four teamsters who were picketing outside a Milton restaurant to secure work as drivers for the nonunion show.
“I felt like he was bullying me,” Lakshmi, 46, said on court on Friday, “like he was telling me he was going to hit me. I could feel my heart beat in my chest.”
Now Blais, 45, is jumping to the defense of the former model, telling PEOPLE: “Padma actually is amazing. She’s one of the coolest people to meet, and she really knows what she’s talking about.”
“I think early on—not anymore because it’s so successful—but a lot of people said, ‘Oh, she’s a pretty model, what does she know about food?’ She is pretty as well, don’t get me wrong, but she knows so much about food and the world,” continues the winner of the show’s all-stars season. “I mean she speaks multiple languages. She’s just amazing.”
And ask for Lakshmi’s famous claim that she keeps three dress sizes on hand during filming, Blais says with a smile: “She says that, but I don’t see it.”